Home » Explore » Salami Mozzarella Eyeballs

Salami Mozzarella Eyeballs

Featured in Dinner

Introduction Looking for a delightfully creepy yet irresistibly delicious appetizer for your Halloween party? These Salami Mozzarella Eyeballs are the ultimate spooky bites that combine savory flavors with ghoulish fun. Fresh mozzarella, pepperoni, olives, and red bell pepper come together

Print it Jump To Recipe

By Manager Blogmerce

Updated on October 11, 2025

Introduction

Looking for a delightfully creepy yet irresistibly delicious appetizer for your Halloween party? These Salami Mozzarella Eyeballs are the ultimate spooky bites that combine savory flavors with ghoulish fun. Fresh mozzarella, pepperoni, olives, and red bell pepper come together to create realistic “eyeballs” that are as tasty as they are eerie. Perfect for Halloween buffets, themed dinners, or kid-friendly spooky nights — they’ll be the talk of your table! Here at Bake Warely, we love crafting recipes that balance creativity and great taste, and this one checks both boxes.

My recipe story

This recipe was born out of my desire to make Halloween treats that aren’t just sweet. While browsing through traditional candy-filled spreads, I realized there wasn’t much for those who crave something savory and satisfying. Inspired by classic Italian antipasto flavors, I turned simple mozzarella balls into little edible eyeballs — with olives as pupils and salami “skin” wrapping them up perfectly. When I first served these at a Halloween gathering, they disappeared faster than a ghost at dawn!

💡 Why You’ll Love This Recipe

Quick and easy to make — no cooking required!
Perfect for Halloween parties or themed dinners.
Rich, savory Italian-inspired flavors.
Fun to assemble — great activity for kids.
Visually striking appetizer that’s Pinterest-worthy.

Ingredient breakdown

Fresh mozzarella balls (12 pieces): Choose a firm type that holds its shape — these form the “eyeballs.”
Kalamata olives (2 tablespoons, chopped): Their deep color mimics eerie pupils and adds a tangy bite.
Pepperoni stick (4 ounces): Slice into thin rounds to form the outer “iris” of each eyeball.
Red bell pepper (1 small): Provides a pop of color — thin strips resemble bloodshot veins for extra spooky flair.

Equipment you’ll need

Small paring knife
Cutting board
Small spoon or melon baller
Toothpicks or cocktail skewers
Serving platter for presentation

Step-by-step directions

Step 1: Prepare the mozzarella “eyeballs”

Start by draining the mozzarella balls and patting them dry with a paper towel. Use a small knife to make a shallow circular cut on the top of each ball — this will create a flat surface for the “pupil.” Be gentle so the cheese doesn’t split. The firmness of the mozzarella helps it maintain the eyeball shape even after handling.

Step 2: Add the olive pupils

Take your chopped Kalamata olives and place a small piece in the indentation you just made. The dark purple hue looks perfectly creepy against the white mozzarella. Press lightly so it sticks but doesn’t sink in too deeply. You can even drizzle a drop of olive brine for a glossy “eye” effect.

Step 3: Slice and shape the pepperoni

Cut thin rounds from your pepperoni stick, ensuring each slice is about the same diameter as your mozzarella balls. The vibrant red color mimics an iris, giving your edible eyes a lifelike appearance. If needed, trim the edges to fit neatly around the mozzarella.

Step 4: Assemble the eyeballs

Place each mozzarella ball in the center of a pepperoni slice and press gently. Add small strips of red bell pepper around the sides for a bloodshot detail. Use toothpicks to secure the layers if serving upright. Arrange them on your platter to resemble a pile of staring eyes — equal parts fun and freaky!

Step 5: Chill and serve

Refrigerate the completed Salami Mozzarella Eyeballs for 20–30 minutes before serving. This helps firm up the cheese and meld the flavors together. Right before guests arrive, remove from the fridge and drizzle lightly with olive oil for shine. Serve alongside other spooky bites like Halloween Caprese Salad Skewers for a colorful party spread.

Variations & substitutions

Vegetarian option: Use roasted red pepper rounds instead of pepperoni.
Different cheeses: Bocconcini or mini babybel halves work great too.
Spice it up: Sprinkle crushed red pepper flakes for a fiery twist.
Olive variety: Try green olives for a lighter “iris” look.
Skewered version: Alternate eyeballs with cherry tomatoes for fun “eyeball kabobs.”

🧠 Expert Tips & Troubleshooting

Use firm mozzarella to prevent tearing during assembly.
Refrigerate before serving for a clean, glossy look.
Toothpicks help secure layers if serving outdoors or for kids.
Add a drop of balsamic glaze for realistic “eye veins.”
For extra creepiness, serve on a dark slate platter.

Storage, freezing & make-ahead

These Salami Mozzarella Eyeballs can be prepared up to 24 hours in advance. Store them in an airtight container in the refrigerator. Avoid freezing, as the texture of the cheese and peppers can change. If making ahead, assemble without the bell pepper strips and add them right before serving to keep their vibrant color and crispness.

Serving ideas & pairings

Serve your Salami Mozzarella Eyeballs with a drizzle of olive oil and balsamic reduction for flavor contrast. They pair beautifully with antipasto platters, cheese boards, or even spooky cocktails like a Bloody Mary. For a full Halloween spread, combine with themed snacks such as mummy pigs, witch’s broomsticks, or stuffed pepper pumpkins. Their salty-savory flavor balances well with crisp white wine or sparkling lemonade.

FAQ

Can I make Salami Mozzarella Eyeballs the night before?

Yes! Assemble them up to 24 hours ahead and keep refrigerated in a sealed container.

Can I use pre-sliced pepperoni?

It’s possible, but stick pepperoni offers a thicker, more realistic look and better structure.

What can I use instead of mozzarella?

Try bocconcini or mini babybel for similar texture and flavor.

How do I make them vegetarian?

Skip the salami and wrap the mozzarella in roasted red pepper strips for the same creepy-cute vibe.

Do these travel well for parties?

Yes — store in a chilled container and reassemble the details on-site if needed for the best presentation.

Final thoughts

These Salami Mozzarella Eyeballs are more than just a spooky treat — they’re a flavorful conversation starter that adds flair to any Halloween party. With simple ingredients and a dash of creativity, you can create eerie, edible eyeballs that everyone will remember. Whether served solo or alongside other hauntingly delicious bites, they’re sure to make your table come alive!